Best Profession in Stardew Valley: Angler or Pirate


If you are planning to become the master of fishing, you will come across the Stardew Valley angler or pirate debate!

This means that you will have to choose the best path for you in terms of fishing professions, and it’s not always such an easy choice! A lot of things depend on what type of gameplay you prefer and what aspects are more valuable to you.

That’s why we will go over the main features of these professions, so that you could make a better decision!

Here is what you need to know about the angler and pirate (and other) professions of the fishing skill:

How to Gain Stardew Fishing Skill?

Before get into the details of the professions, you need to know the easiest ways to level up your fishing skill in the game.

The best way to do that is by catching fish, trash, all types of algae, and even seaweed. You can also harvest from your crab pots if you have them nearby.

Fishing is a very useful skill, so definitely try to work on it right from the beginning of the game.

Level 5 Fishing Choices in Stardew Valley

Once you reach level 5, you will have to make the first choice between two professions. The options are fisher and trapper.

If you choose to be a fisher, you will later have to choose to either be a Stardew Valley angler or pirate. The level 5 profession allows you to get fish that is 25% more valuable. This is a great option if you plan to go fishing a lot.

On the other hand, you can choose to be a trapper. With this choice, you will need less items to make crab pots. This choice depends a lot on what type of fishing you like to do. Of course, the fisher option is more basic, but it also means that more players can benefit from it. You can even collect your fish bundles easier if you are a better fisher!

That’s just one of the reasons why many players suggest that the fisher option is better.

Level 10 Fishing Choices in Stardew Valley

This is where things get interesting with the whole Stardew angler or pirate topic!

If you have chosen to be a fisher, you will have to pick between becoming an angler and a pirate. If you have chosen to be a trapper, on the other hand, you will have to choose between being a mariner or a luremaster.

Let’s see what these options will bring you.

Being an angler makes your fish be 50% more valuable, and the pirate options gives you an opportunity to find more treasure. Many players agree that the Stardew pirate option is much more interesting! The chance of finding treasure is always exciting, so of course many will choose this.

Then again, if you choose to be a mariner, you won’t find any more junk items in your crab pots. If you work a lot on your crab pots, this will be a great addition to your gameplay. Crab pots can bring you plenty of gold, so definitely consider this!

The last option is the luremaster. If you choose this path, you won’t need any more bait for your crab pots. This makes the process easier and faster, so this might be a harder choice.

Which Fishing Profession Should You Choose in Stardew?

There are a lot of discussions, but the best option does seem to be pirate! You will need to work a lot on your fishing skills, but this will make the game much more exciting!

Of course, there are other things to consider depending on what you need in the game. Any chosen path will bring great upgrades, so any of the 4 paths is worth your time. With this one, you mostly just have to choose between regular phishing and using crab pots. One that decision is made, it will be easier to choose!

While you’re at it, take a look at our other guides where we dive deeper into Stardew Valley professions:

So, which path seems the best for your character? Choose well!

meet the Author

Photo of author
"Ever since I started playing Stardew Valley, I wanted to find the best tips and tricks to make the game easier and even more entertaining. That’s why I love sharing my favourite insights with other Stardew fans to see what can be useful both for beginners and experienced players!"

Popular Content

Learn about the most profitable crops for each season to make the most profit. Just follow the link to find our definite farming guide!

What is the best profession? Professions in Stardew Valley have their very own pros and cons. Learn if the miner or geologist profession is better for you!

More Content you may like: